Islam: why and how? Episode 53

Did the Quran Make a Mathematical Error in Inheritance Calculations?

4:35

4:35

In this video, we examine one of the most controversial and common criticisms leveled against the Quran by critics: the claim of a mathematical error in the rules of inheritance! Did God really encounter a problem in simple fractional addition (shares of father, mother, wife, and daughters), resulting in a shortage of inheritance? In this episode, while thoroughly examining this doubt and critiquing the "Rule of 'Awl" (the doctrine of proportioning) devised by some jurists, we explore the miraculous and logical solution provided by the Quran itself and the Ahl al-Bayt (a.s.), demonstrating that the key to solving this puzzle lies in understanding the "classes and priorities" of relatives.

Topics covered in this video:

Examining critics' claims regarding mathematical errors in Quranic inheritance distribution

Analyzing a challenging example: shares of father, mother, wife, and two daughters

Introduction to the "Rule of 'Awl" in jurisprudence, origins, and criticisms against it

A look at the opposition of Ahl al-Bayt (a.s.) and certain companions to the Rule of 'Awl

Discovering the true solution within Quranic verses based on the hierarchy of heirs

Timestamps:

Social Media & Contact Links:

YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@kalam-hamidhossaini

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/kalam_hamidhosseini

Telegram: https://t.me/hamidhossaini

Support us in producing logical content and responding to religious doubts by subscribing to the channel and turning on the notification bell. Be sure to share your thoughts in the comments!

Chapters

  1. 0:00 Introduction and raising the doubt of mathematical errors in Quranic calculations
  2. 0:43 Overview of inheritance rules and shares in Quranic verses
  3. 1:22 The controversial example of fractional addition failure (sum exceeding 1)
  4. 2:20 Resorting to the "Rule of 'Awl": A solution devised by some jurists to solve the issue
  5. 3:36 Flaws and consequences of the Rule of 'Awl and reduction of true heirs' shares
  6. 5:05 The Prophet's Ahl al-Bayt (a.s.) opposition to 'Awl and explanation of divine mathematical perfection
  7. 5:44 Quran's inheritance design based on classes and priorities
  8. 6:44 Applying the Quran's exact formula to the example and solving the puzzle without 'Awl
  9. 7:11 Conclusion: The necessity of referring to the Quran and its true interpreters

Try

Tips

  • Vowel marks are optional: الرحمن finds ٱلرَّحْمَٰنِ.
  • Put words in quotes for an exact phrase.
  • Jump to a verse with 2:255 or “Baqarah 255”.